How to Choose the Best Harness & Leash for Your Dog

Standing in front of a wall of harnesses and leashes — or scrolling endlessly online — reveals the mind-boggling amount of products available just for the simple task of walking your dog. With so many options, how do you know which one is best for your pet?

Like many products for your dog, the buying decision should be based on their specific needs as well as yours. The key is to match your gear to your dog’s size, breed, and your shared lifestyle. In this guide, we’ll break down the most popular types of harnesses and leashes, what to look for in each, and how to choose the right fit for your furry friend.

Harness vs. Collar: Why a Harness May Be Best for Walks

While collars are great for ID tags and quick trips outside, a harness is often the better choice for walks, hikes, and training. This is because harnesses:

• Provide more control without putting pressure on the neck
• Distribute weight evenly across the chest and shoulders
• Help reduce pulling (especially front-clip styles)
• Can be more comfortable for your dog

Types of Dog Harnesses (And When to Use Each)

Every dog should have a collar for holding ID tags, but for active outings, a quality harness is often the better choice. Here’s a breakdown of the most common types:

1. Back-Clip Harness

This common harness style features a D-ring on the back for attaching a dog leash. They’re simple, versatile, and easy to use — though not ideal for strong pullers.

Best for: Easygoing dogs and casual walks
Pros: Simple design, less tangling
Consider: Not great for dogs that pull

2. Front-Clip (No-Pull) Harness

This type places the leash attachment at the chest, encouraging better leash manners and giving pet parents more control. Often referred to as a no-pull dog harness.

Best for: Dogs in training or those who pull
Pros: Helps manage pulling
Consider: May require practice to avoid tangling

3. Dual-Clip Harness

A versatile option with both front and back attachment points. Great for switching between relaxed walks and more controlled training sessions.

Best for: Active lifestyles and versatility
Pros: Front or back clip depending on activity
Consider: Bulkier than single-clip harnesses

4. Backpack or Day Pack Harness

Featuring built-in saddlebags, these harnesses let your dog carry essentials on hikes or camping trips. Choose carefully for dogs prone to back issues.

Best for: Hikers and campers
Pros: Storage for food, water, and gear
Consider: Avoid for dogs with back problems

5. Safety Harness (Car Harness)

Designed for car travel, this harness acts like a seatbelt by attaching to your vehicle’s safety belt system. Not intended for walking use.

Best for: Traveling safely with your dog
Pros: Helps keep dogs secure during drives
Consider: Not suitable for everyday walks

What to Look for in a Dog Harness

• Fit & Size: Should be snug but not tight — two fingers should fit under the straps.
• Material: Look for strong, easy-to-clean options like nylon or polyester.
• Visibility: Reflective or bright colors improve safety.
• Design: Step-in or over-the-head depending on your dog’s comfort.
• Construction: Reinforced stitching is key.
• Hardware: Durable buckles and metal D-rings last longer.

Types of Dog Leashes (And When to Use Each)

Once you’ve chosen a harness, pair it with the right dog leash. Different types suit different dogs, activities, and training needs.

1. Flat Leash

The classic leash style — durable, simple, and available in various lengths.

Best for: Everyday walks
Pros: Reliable, available in many materials and lengths

2. Slip Leash

A leash-and-collar combo that slips over the head. Useful for quick control but not ideal for long-term use.

Best for: Quick control or emergencies
Pros: Fast to put on
Consider: Can tighten and cause choking if misused

3. Hands-Free Leash

Often worn around the waist, this leash frees up your hands while hiking or running.

Best for: Runners, hikers
Pros: Comfortable and practical

4. Off-Leash Leash (Grab Handle)

A short handle for quick control during off-leash activities. Best for medium and large breeds.

Best for: Off-leash training
Pros: Easy to grab without dragging

5. Retractable Leash

A long cord housed inside a handle. Provides adjustable freedom but less control and greater safety risks.

Best for: Limited controlled freedom
Pros: Adjustable length
Consider: Tangling, poor control, potential breakage

What to Look for in a Dog Leash

• Length: 6 ft for daily walks; shorter for training; long lines for recall practice.
• Material: Nylon and rope are versatile; leather is stylish but less water-friendly.
• Visibility: Reflective materials help after dark.
• Design: Comfortable grip, extra clips for bags or treats.
• Construction: Quality stitching or strong metal links.
• Hardware: Choose metal clasps for safety.

Final Tips: You Don’t Need Just One!

Different harnesses or leashes may work better for different scenarios — city walks, hiking trails, training sessions, and more. Mix and match until you find the setup that best fits your dog’s needs and your lifestyle.

Ready to upgrade your walk gear? Explore high-quality leashes, collars, and harnesses at Only Natural Pet.